From the Earth · Gemstone Origins & Geology
The short answer: A Herkimer diamond is not a diamond. The name refers to exceptionally well-formed quartz crystals associated with the Herkimer region of New York State. Their clear appearance and naturally pointed ends can make them look almost cut by hand, even when their crystal faces formed entirely in the earth.
That distinction is part of what makes them interesting. A diamond owes its identity to carbon and its extraordinary hardness. A Herkimer diamond belongs to the quartz family. Its appeal lies in a particular natural crystal shape, the geology behind it, and the small differences that make one crystal unlike another.
What is a Herkimer diamond, exactly?
In mineralogical terms, it is quartz (silicon dioxide, SiO₂). The word “diamond” is a historic nickname, not a statement that the crystal is made of diamond. Herkimer quartz is especially known for being double terminated: it can have a natural point at each end, rather than a point at one end and a broken or attached base at the other.
Its faces can be remarkably crisp. Those flat surfaces are the crystal's own growth faces, not necessarily facets cut by a lapidary. The shape is one reason raw Herkimer-style quartz works so beautifully in jewelry: the stone arrives with a silhouette worth preserving.
The locality name matters too. Strictly speaking, “Herkimer diamond” refers to the quartz crystals associated with Herkimer County and the surrounding Mohawk Valley area of New York. Similar double-terminated quartz occurs in other parts of the world, but a similar shape alone does not establish a New York origin. Geologist Hobart M. King explains this distinction in his overview of the crystals and their locality.
Where do Herkimer diamonds come from?
The best-known locality is the area around Herkimer County, including the communities of Middleville and Little Falls in central New York. There, collectors find quartz crystals in cavities within the Little Falls Dolostone, a sedimentary rock unit from the Cambrian Period.
The dolostone was deposited roughly 500 million years ago in an ancient shallow-marine setting. Over time, openings developed in the rock. Silica-bearing fluids moved through those spaces, and quartz crystallized within them. Importantly, the age of the host rock is not automatically the precise age of every crystal; the crystals formed within cavities in that older rock.
The University of Waterloo's geological field account describes the dolostone, its cavities and the unusual quartz crystals found there. It's a useful reminder that the sparkle we see in a finished pendant began with an entirely different landscape.
Why do some Herkimer crystals have points at both ends?
Most people picture a crystal growing up from a rock surface, with a visible point at the top. In an open cavity, however, a quartz crystal may have room to develop crystal faces at both ends. That freedom of growth helps explain the double-terminated shape.
Not every specimen looks perfectly symmetrical. One end may be broader, a point may be interrupted, or the middle may be shorter or longer. These variations are not design flaws. They are evidence that the crystal grew under its own particular conditions.
Some specimens are nearly water-clear; others have veils, cloudy areas or dark inclusions. Inclusions can record aspects of a crystal's formation, but their appearance alone cannot prove a precise mine, treatment history or geographic origin.

Herkimer diamond vs real diamond: what's the difference?
They can look similar at a glance, but they are different minerals.
- Mineral composition: Herkimer quartz is silicon dioxide (SiO₂); diamond is carbon.
- Hardness: Quartz ranks 7 on the Mohs scratch-hardness scale; diamond ranks 10.
- Appearance: Herkimer quartz is admired for natural points and crystal faces. Faceted diamonds are commonly cut and polished to emphasize their optical properties.
- Jewelry care: Quartz is suitable for many jewelry designs, but its points can still chip from impact. A Mohs number describes scratch resistance, not immunity to breakage.
The Gemological Institute of America identifies diamond as carbon with a Mohs hardness of 10. Its explanation of the Mohs scale also makes an important distinction between hardness and toughness.
From a natural crystal to a necklace in our Toronto studio
At Designs by Nature Gems, we don't begin by asking every raw crystal to fit the same outline. We look at the shape already there: where the points sit, how the light moves through the stone, and which areas should remain visible once it is wrapped.
Wire wrapping gives us room to work with those differences. A longer crystal may call for a different balance than a compact one. An inclusion or an unusually shaped termination can become part of what makes a piece appealing, rather than something to conceal.
That is also why we offer Choose Your Exact Stone on eligible designs. Instead of assuming two raw crystals are interchangeable, we invite customers to see available options and select the one that feels right to them before their piece is completed. Learn more about the people and process behind our work in How It's Made: The Hands Behind Every Stone.
Explore handcrafted Herkimer diamond jewelry
There isn't one way to wear a clear raw crystal. The metal, setting and scale can change its character considerably. Here are a few designs from our current catalog:
- Raw Herkimer Diamond Necklace for Women — Sterling Silver: an expressive wire-wrapped pendant that leaves the natural shape at the centre.
- Genuine Herkimer Diamond Necklace — 14k Gold Filled Chain: a warm-metal interpretation of the raw crystal.
- Minimalist Herkimer Diamond & Silver Lotus Necklace: a smaller crystal paired with a sterling silver lotus charm.
- Herkimer Diamond Sterling Silver Drop Earrings: another way to bring the crystal's natural geometry into an everyday design.

Curious about the metal around your stone? Our guide to gold-filled, gold-plated and vermeil jewelry explains the difference. For looking after a raw crystal and its setting, see our jewelry care guide.
How to choose your own raw quartz crystal
Clarity is one consideration, but it needn't be the only one. Look at the length and shape of the crystal, the character of its points, and any visible inclusions. Some people prefer a nearly transparent stone; others are drawn to the texture and individuality of a more included crystal.
Think about how you'll wear it, too. A delicate pendant and a larger statement necklace have different proportions. Neither is inherently better; the right choice is the one that suits the wearer and the design.
A note on provenance: The geology above describes the classic Herkimer, New York locality. It should not be read as confirmation that every individual crystal in our catalog was mined there. We do not assign a specific mining origin or treatment history to an individual piece in this article without supporting sourcing records.
Frequently asked questions
Are Herkimer diamonds real diamonds?
No. They are quartz crystals. The “diamond” nickname comes from their clarity and naturally defined crystal faces, not from their mineral composition.
Are Herkimer diamonds naturally faceted?
They can have remarkably flat, reflective faces formed during crystal growth. These are natural crystal faces rather than proof that a stone has been cut or polished.
Do all double-terminated quartz crystals come from Herkimer, New York?
No. Similar quartz crystals occur elsewhere. A double-terminated shape does not, by itself, establish a Herkimer-area origin.
Are inclusions in Herkimer quartz a defect?
Not necessarily. Inclusions and internal veils are natural features in many quartz specimens. Whether you prefer a clear or more included crystal is a personal and aesthetic choice.
Is Herkimer quartz durable enough for a necklace?
Quartz has a Mohs hardness of 7, but pointed crystals can still chip or fracture if struck. Avoid impacts, store the necklace separately and follow care guidance for both the stone and its metal setting.
Can I choose the exact crystal in my necklace?
On eligible Designs by Nature Gems pieces, yes. Our Choose Your Exact Stone experience lets you review available natural stones before your necklace is completed.
The beauty of a shape nature made
A Herkimer diamond isn't a diamond trying to be something else. It is quartz with a remarkable geological story and a form that needs little embellishment. For us, that is the pleasure of working with raw gemstones: each stone brings something to the design before a single piece of wire is wrapped.
Explore our handcrafted raw Herkimer diamond necklace →
Research and further reading: Geology.com, “Herkimer Diamonds,” by Hobart M. King, PhD; University of Waterloo, “Field tripping — collecting Herkimer Diamond quartz”; GIA, Diamond; GIA, Mohs Scale. This article distinguishes geological background from the unverified provenance of individual jewelry stones.



